In Hogwarts Legacy, players are given the chance to form deep friendships with several key companions, each with their own backstories, quests, and moral perspectives. Two of the most compelling and narrative-rich characters are Sebastian Sallow and Natsai Natty Onai. These two offer contrasting worldviews and gameplay experiences, which has led many players to ask a critical question: who should you side with more closely Sebastian or Natty? Understanding both characters’ motivations, strengths, and unique contributions to the story is essential for players who want to get the most out of their Hogwarts Legacy experience.
Character Backgrounds
Sebastian Sallow The Cursed Rebel
Sebastian Sallow is a Slytherin student whose journey is heavily intertwined with dark magic and personal sacrifice. His twin sister, Anne, suffers from a mysterious curse, and Sebastian becomes obsessed with finding a cure even if it means delving into forbidden magic. His narrative arc is filled with emotional turmoil, moral ambiguity, and the complex question of whether the ends justify the means.
Throughout his questline, Sebastian exposes you to the darker aspects of magic, including the Unforgivable Curses. He challenges Hogwarts’ rigid rules and believes that power, even dangerous power, can be used for good if wielded with the right intent.
Natsai Onai The Principled Protector
Natsai Natty Onai, a Gryffindor student originally from Uagadou (a prestigious wizarding school in Africa), stands in direct contrast to Sebastian. Her story revolves around her mother’s role in law enforcement and her own desire to see justice served. Natty is driven by duty, righteousness, and the idea of using magic responsibly. She has a strong moral compass and is always concerned about doing the right thing even when it’s hard.
Her questline takes you through themes of justice, truth-seeking, and resistance against corruption. Natty’s storyline appeals to players who prefer structure, integrity, and a strong sense of purpose over chaotic or emotionally driven choices.
Gameplay Differences and Perks
While both characters offer meaningful quests and immersive storylines, there are gameplay elements that can influence which character you prefer to align with more deeply.
Sebastian’s Gameplay Impact
- Unlocks the Unforgivable Curses: Crucio, Imperio, and Avada Kedavra
- His missions include more combat-heavy and dungeon-like experiences
- Opportunities to explore hidden areas tied to ancient magic
- Dialogues often involve moral choices and ethical dilemmas
Sebastian’s questline is ideal for players who enjoy morally gray narratives, dark lore, and challenging combat scenarios. The spells you unlock through him can significantly enhance your power in battle, but they also bring consequences not all NPCs will respond positively if you use dark magic openly.
Natty’s Gameplay Impact
- Missions emphasize stealth, diplomacy, and protection of others
- More focused on narrative-driven content and resistance themes
- Dialogues offer insight into international wizarding perspectives
- Reinforces the use of spells in a controlled, heroic manner
Natty’s quests are more aligned with players who want to play as a classic hero someone who follows the rules, stands against injustice, and protects the innocent. She provides a refreshing, idealistic perspective that helps balance the darker tones found elsewhere in the game.
Moral Alignment and Player Identity
One of the strengths of Hogwarts Legacy is its emphasis on player choice and moral alignment. Choosing to side more often with Sebastian or Natty can reflect how you view the use of magic, power, and responsibility in a world where rules and history are not always just.
Choosing Sebastian
If you gravitate toward Sebastian, you might value autonomy, the freedom to question authority, and a willingness to take risks for the ones you love. His journey is emotionally complex and forces you to consider whether breaking the rules can be morally justified. But it also comes with consequences characters may judge you, and your actions can lead to irreversible decisions.
Choosing Natty
Siding with Natty signals a desire to uphold justice, seek truth, and embody the nobler aspects of being a witch or wizard. Her route is less about raw power and more about moral clarity. If you value structure, loyalty, and heroic ideals, her questline will resonate deeply with your playstyle.
Companion Dialogues and Emotional Resonance
Both Sebastian and Natty offer meaningful companion dialogues that reveal more about your character’s relationships and personality. These interactions go beyond quests and shape how you are perceived in the wider world of Hogwarts and beyond.
- Sebastian’s conversations: Often intense, emotionally charged, and filled with moral conflict.
- Natty’s conversations: Thoughtful, justice-focused, and filled with compassionate insight.
The emotional depth of both characters is one of the highlights of the game. You may find yourself feeling torn sympathizing with Sebastian’s desperation but admiring Natty’s unwavering strength. The decision between them doesn’t always come down to gameplay or spell access sometimes, it’s about who you connect with more.
Impact on the Story
While Hogwarts Legacy doesn’t force you to make a definitive choice between Sebastian and Natty, your actions during their quests can affect the ending and your relationship with them. In particular, Sebastian’s arc includes some irreversible choices, including whether or not he learns Avada Kedavra and whether you support him or oppose him.
Natty’s arc also culminates in a mission where your choices impact her perception of you. Aligning with her values can lead to more favorable dialogue, and her approval can affect how some final missions play out thematically, even if not mechanically.
Who Should You Choose: Sebastian or Natty?
There’s no wrong answer the game is designed to reflect your choices, and both characters are fully fleshed out. But here’s a general breakdown to help guide your decision based on your preferred experience:
- Choose Sebastian if: You enjoy dark narratives, challenging combat, and exploring forbidden power. You’re okay with moral ambiguity and want access to powerful spells like Avada Kedavra.
- Choose Natty if: You prefer playing as a noble hero, enjoy structured quests centered around justice, and align with traditional heroic values. You value diplomacy over brute force.
Some players may choose to balance both, completing both questlines without heavily favoring either. That’s also a valid path, especially for completionists or those who want a well-rounded experience.
In Hogwarts Legacy, the decision to side more closely with Sebastian or Natty is a reflection of who you are as a player. It’s about more than just combat abilities or magical spells it’s about the kind of witch or wizard you want to become. Whether you walk the shadowy path with Sebastian or stand tall in the light with Natty, each journey offers a rich narrative, compelling choices, and unforgettable moments. Choose the path that resonates with your vision of your Hogwarts legacy and remember, magic is only as good or evil as the hand that wields it.